Jesse Welch runs Midcap Global, a boutique investment bank advising companies with $1 million to over $10 million in profits. He came from film production, AI startups, a real estate private equity firm and a crypto hedge fund sold in 2021, and he now teaches founders on his Capital Love Letters YouTube channel.
His core point: the headline exit price is a vanity metric; it’s the other terms that decide who gets paid, how much and when. He walks through earnouts, rollover equity, escrows, consent rights, preferred equity, PIK interest and ratchets, and shows how each one can be turned against a founder who signs without understanding it.
He also covers newer traps for software sellers, including annual prepay contracts that trigger working capital demands, plus quality of earnings reports and family office buyers. His advice: build a three-person team with a CPA, lawyer and M&A advisor, stay patient and flexible, and assume every clause gets used against you.
Key Takeaways
- Earnout Odds – About 25% of lower middle market deals include one, and the market pays around 21 cents on the dollar.
- Consent Rights – Assume every clause gets weaponized against you; Jesse puts the odds at forty to fifty percent.
- Preferred Equity – Liquidation preferences, participation and PIK interest put investors first in line, and time works against the founder.
- Prepay Contracts – Buyers may demand part of the annual cash you collected stay behind; negotiate to the real cost of service.
- Advisor Team – Hire a CPA, a lawyer and an M&A advisor, because lawyers make deals legal, not strategic.
Quote from Jesse Welch, Founder and CEO of Midcap Global
“Earnouts are tools that can be used to trap you. About 25% of lower middle market deals have one, and they’re sold as a second bite at the apple, but they don’t tell you if that apple’s rotten or if there’s a worm in it. When I’m representing a buyer I always push for an earnout, but for a founder it’s an extremely dangerous tool.
“Say you want to sell at $200 million and the buyer wants to pay $190 million. To bridge that ten-million gap, they’ll ask you to work for them for two years, with five million for each year if the company hits certain metrics, usually a profit number. It sounds great because you know your business and you can grow it to that number, but you’re betting on the same horse with a different jockey.
“The buyer can reduce your marketing spend, add a monitoring fee and throw overhead onto your business, so a ten-million profit target lands at $9.9 million. You don’t get 90 percent of your earnout for getting 90 percent of the way there; you might work for two years and walk away with zero. About half of earnouts pay out nothing, and across the entire market they pay around 21 cents on the dollar.”
Links